Protester skates his way to five days in jail

Published Thursday May 15th, 2008
A1

A pro-skateboarding and environmental activist surrendered himself to sheriff's officers Wednesday afternoon for non-payment of a fine, but not before more than 100 supporters marched, skateboarded and cycled with him to the courthouse.

1 of 2
Click to Enlarge
Click to Enlarge
MAKING A STAND FOR SKATEBOARDERS: lee Breen, centre, in the black helmet, rides his skateboard along york Street with a crowd of supporters after leaving a rally in support of him in front of Fredericton city hall. they paraded through downtown to the Justice Building, where he surrendered to sheriff's officers. Breen's brother Fergus is shown with the skateboard over his head behind the police car.

Lee Breen, 25, was recently found guilty of violating a city bylaw prohibiting skateboarding on city streets. He was fined $100 but declined to pay it.

A provincial court judge gave him until Wednesday to pay the fine, but he chose to do the five days of jail time in default of payment.

Before he did so, he and others organized a rally in front of city hall in protest of the nuisance bylaw and Breen's jail term.

Protesters held signs encouraging motorists to honk if in protest of the bylaw, and they got plenty of positive responses.

Breen said he decided to oppose the bylaw and go to jail so people would talk about the issue, and he's pleased that he's done that.

But there's more work ahead, he said.

"I wouldn't say I feel like I accomplished anything yet," he said.

He said skateboarders should be allowed to use city streets because it's a viable and environmentally friendly mode of transportation.

"There's a huge skateboarding community here in Fredericton," he said.

Breen has visited other communities where skateboarding on the street is welcome, he said.

Inez Rudderham is a fellow skateboarder, and she uses a longboard - a longer skateboard designed mainly for transportation - to get around the city.

She attended the rally Wednesday to support Breen and to help to open people's eyes about the issue.

"I want to show the city we're not all punks and deviants," she said.

"There's a huge stereotype about skateboarders."

City spokesman Wayne Knorr said Wednesday that skateboarding on city streets endangers the boarders and motorists.

"This is really about public safety," he said.

He said the argument that skateboarders take up no more room on city streets than cyclists doesn't apply because the provincial Motor Vehicle Act specifically allows bikes on roadways.

Section 176 of that act states: "Every person riding a bicycle upon a roadway has all of the rights and is subject to all of the duties applicable to the driver of a vehicle by this Act, except those provisions which by their very nature can have no application."

The bylaw prohibiting skateboarding on Fredericton streets comes under the city's nuisance bylaw.

Rudderham uses her board to get to and from work, she said, leaving no carbon imprint on the environment.

She's never been cited for using her board on the street, though police have warned her to be careful.

Motorists and pedestrians aren't nearly as polite as police are when dealing with skateboarders, she said.

Downtown business owner Luke Randall said the city's explanations for banning boards on the street don't make sense.

"I think the city is making a very uneducated statement," he said. "I have more problems with drivers running red lights and hitting pedestrians."

The City of Fredericton needs to expand its thinking about environmental issues and embrace other forms of transport that don't produce emissions, such as skateboards and scooters, he said.

Randall said one solution may be to lobby the province for changes to the Motor Vehicle Act to include other eco-friendly modes of transport along with bicycles.

At 1 p.m., the crowd marched, rode and skated from city hall, up York Street, east on King, down Carleton and up Queen Street until Breen reached the Justice Building, where he surrendered himself, a few hours before his arrest warrant was actually processed.

Before beginning the protest procession, Fergus Breen, Lee Breen's brother, encouraged supporters to lobby their city councillors and Mayor Brad Woodside for a change to the bylaw.

He also urged everyone to write letters and keep campaigning against the bylaw.

Lee Breen, who runs a lawn-care business, said he plans to continue his efforts to lobby the city for a change.

He said newly elected UNB/College Hill councillor Jordan Graham has pledged his support.

Graham couldn't be reached for comment Wednesday.

Please Log In or Register FREE

You are currently not logged into this site. Please log in or register for a FREE ONE Account.
Logged in visitors may comment on articles, enter contests, manage home delivery holds and much more online. Your ONE Account grants you access to features and content across the entire CanadaEast Network of sites.

Comments (17)

All comments are subject to the site Terms of Use. For a full commenting tutorial click here.

Our editorial team relies on filtering technology and our visitor community to identify inappropriate comments. In the event that a site user has submitted offensive content that has evaded our filter, please select the option to Flag As Inappropriate presented within the comment. Thank you for helping to keep this site clean.

Having driven in Fredericton, I do not think having skateboarders on the city streets would be a good idea at all. What kind of training would there be? What mandatory safety equipment would be used? It is sometimes difficult enough to navigate a motor vehicle around cyclists (who sometimes follow road laws, and other times follow pedestrian laws)without adding skateboarders into the mix. There is a reason why skateboards are not allowed, I believe, it is for their own safety. If the by-law was to be changed, and skateboarders allowed on city streets, it would only be a matter of time before someone was injured, or worse, killed, on the road. And then what? Please keep your hobby in the skate parks.
31
Thumbs Up
34
Thumbs Down
Flag as Inappropriate
Flag as Inappropriate
m. macquarrie, Fredericton on 15/05/08, 6:59:35 AM ADT
I think as long as skaters stay on the sidewalks and not on the roads, everything will be fine. It is as the story suggests, a viable transportation method. Good for your health too. Especially the long boards, which are meant for transportation over tricks. Banning those boards basically makes them useless to purchase.
31
Thumbs Up
19
Thumbs Down
Flag as Inappropriate
Flag as Inappropriate
J. Desjardins, Fredericton on 15/05/08, 7:10:55 AM ADT
Having the skateboarders on the sidewalks is not the best plan. I wish I had a dime for every time I have swerved to avoid a boarder since he/she was not going to swerve to avoid me. There is a time and place for everything... sidewalks at 4:30 and lunch time is not the time.
30
Thumbs Up
13
Thumbs Down
Flag as Inappropriate
Flag as Inappropriate
Anonymous Reader on 15/05/08, 7:56:20 AM ADT
I think that skateboarders should stay off the road.. people don't know how to drive around fredericton and someone is going to get ran over.. if you can't do the speed limit stay off the roads there is no need for them to be on there!
22
Thumbs Up
21
Thumbs Down
Flag as Inappropriate
Flag as Inappropriate
Anonymous Reader on 15/05/08, 8:00:32 AM ADT
Anti-skateboarding arises from anti-youth culture and our society's general criminalization of youth. Most of our discomfort over skateboarding arises from this hostility towards youth.
If the city of Fredericton is truly committed to reducing greenhouse gases and reaching the Kyoto targets before any other Canadian city (which I have yet to be convinced they are - until I see some legislative action) then they should support the use of non-carbon emitting transportation. It requires not just changes to bylaws, but a shift in culture. An acceptance of skateboards and long boards as transportation, and responsible use of the above.
Good for Breen for drawing attention to this.
31
Thumbs Up
17
Thumbs Down
Flag as Inappropriate
Flag as Inappropriate
T. Kim, Fredericton on 15/05/08, 8:21:58 AM ADT
I doubt he received his ticket for being 'on the street' he was more than likely riding the sidewalk - so like a cyclist should have been fined.

I've worked downtown and in the good weather there are literally packs of these skaters roving around down town. I've seen many skaters come down that section of Queen street, the only 'street portion' of their trip is if they need to cross and they don't use the walk light.

It's not a judgment on what kind of person they are - just how unruly and unsafe they make sidewalks, I feel the same way about bikers on sidewalks and rollerbladers on the streets skiing along.

The streets aren't safe, but on the same token the sidewalks are made unsafe by moving these "modes of transportation" to the side"walk".

Standing up for yourself is one thing, hiding it behind environmentalism is a cheap shield for the real issue.
29
Thumbs Up
16
Thumbs Down
Flag as Inappropriate
Flag as Inappropriate
Anonymous Reader on 15/05/08, 8:24:31 AM ADT
He isn't "hiding behind environmentalism", he's doing what this city is supposedly trying to promote. I can't believe Fredericton's hypocracy.

"Be green. But only if it's convenient for others."

No. You can't have it both ways. Do you want "green matters", or not?

Agree with the other above poster...the problem here is the attitude and vast generalization of youth. He was wearing a helmet, using a longboard (designed for travel), and driving with the flow of traffic (similar to a bicycle).

BTW, he's not "a kid", he's in his mid-20s.
31
Thumbs Up
16
Thumbs Down
Flag as Inappropriate
Flag as Inappropriate
Darren M., Fredericton on 15/05/08, 8:35:41 AM ADT
Riding bicycle doesn't make noise. Skateboarding does, and that is a perfect example of SOUND POLLUTION. Just because skateboarding doesn't burn gas, it doesn't mean that it is GREEN.

11
Thumbs Up
24
Thumbs Down
Flag as Inappropriate
Flag as Inappropriate
Anonymous Reader on 15/05/08, 9:43:23 AM ADT
Police in Fredericton should be more concerned with its' citizens and visitors being killed and/or injured by poor drivers. This is another example of Fredericton's idiotic police force ignoring the real crime in the city and hassling a law abiding citizen. This story does not make Fredericton look like one of the top ten most "intelligent" citizens in North America. Shame on the mayor Woodside and the Fredericton Police Force.
15
Thumbs Up
11
Thumbs Down
Flag as Inappropriate
Flag as Inappropriate
Eddie Vedder, Freddy Beach on 15/05/08, 10:18:11 AM ADT
What about these cars with their "Canadian Tire fart can" mufflers. Bikes with no mufflers at all" Thats the noise pollution.

We have a great population of young people concerned about our future, And the envrioment that they will be growin up in. Skate borading, rollerblading etc is a great way to start to make change. Just this winter I have seen people cross country sking on queen street. Sure its probably illigal but at the same time what are they hurting.

Fredericton residents are so afraid of change. we complain about anything that is being updated or new ideas of something. Change cannot happen without open minds.

And next time you want to write something that looks down on skateboarders etc just think that will be your grandchildren fighting and standing up for what they belive in someday
17
Thumbs Up
3
Thumbs Down
Flag as Inappropriate
Flag as Inappropriate
Anonymous Reader on 15/05/08, 10:21:30 AM ADT
Advertisement
Advertisement

Search Articles